regshoe asked for my favourite stories from my Christmas mystery short story collections. Here are a few [in no order, with the anthology in brackets].
I like Clever. More than atmosphere, characters, or anything else.
1. "Death on Christmas Eve" by Stanley Ellin. I love Stanley Ellin, and in terms of role models for my own writing, he's definitely one of them. This is the story of a lawyer's encounter with a highly dysfunctional family. [
Murder for Christmas, ed. by Thomas Godfrey]
2. all four stories in P.D. James'
The Mistletoe Murder and other stories with a special gift in the stocking for the final two which are Adam Dalgliesh tales, "The Boxdale Inheritance," which is a very, very clever twist, and "The 12 Clues of Christmas" which is a spoof of Agatha Christie, but very well done.
3. "The Trinity Cat" by Ellis Peters (of Cadfael fame). An old lady gets murdered and a stray cat reveals clues. [
Murder on Christmas Eve, edited by Cecily Gayford].
4. "On Christmas Day in the Morning" by Margery Allingham. Campion as detective and the critical clue is rather a sweet one. [
A Surprise for Christmas and Other Seasonal Mysteries ed by Martin Edwards].
5. "Sister Bessie or Your Old Leech" by Cyril Hare. An excellent blackmailing story. [
The Christmas Card Crime and Other Stories edited by Martin Edwards].